People living in a democracy often take its benefits and processes for granted, overlooking the intricacies inherent in its evolution. One significant, yet seemingly straightforward, challenge democracies face is the apportionment problem: determining the appropriate number of representatives for a specific electorate.
A representative democracy heavily depends on the equitable representation of voices. However, defining "equitable representation" is far from simple. For instance, during the establishment of the US democracy, there was extensive debate. One major contention was whether to give each state an equal number of representatives or allocate proportionally based on the state's population. In the US, the compromise led to the Senate having equal seats for each state, while the House's allocation was based on population.
Most democracies opt for proportional allocation by population, whereby dividing each region's population from the latest census by the total seems to provide an appropriate percentage of representatives. However, the devil is in the details. Such calculations can yield fractions instead of whole numbers, introducing complexities in allocation. Deciding how to handle these fractional results is tricky since simple rounding would mean a variable number of representatives depending on the outcomes. This challenge led to the development of various methods in the 19th and 20th centuries, such as the de Hondt and Sainte-Laguë methods, both of which begin by dividing the votes.
The choice of allocation method has tangible implications. For example, the de Hondt method tends to favor larger parties, while Sainte-Laguë provides more opportunities for smaller parties. It has been mathematically proven that no method can guarantee a 100% fair allocation. Democracy exists on a spectrum, and like many contemporary concepts, it is always evolving, with both science and mathematics playing pivotal roles in refining and advancing our democratic ideals, reminding us that the pursuit of a perfect democracy is an ongoing journey we must collectively undertake.
Craving more? Check out the source behind this Brain Snack!
